John & Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Located in the heart of the Bronx at 749 Lydig Ave, John & Joe's Pizzeria and Restaurant is a beloved neighborhood gem that brings authentic Italian-American flavors to life with every bite. Specializing in classic New York-style pizza, this cozy pizzeria delivers a mouthwatering menu that has won the hearts—and taste buds—of locals and visitors alike.

At John & Joe’s, the pizza is nothing short of a masterpiece. From their quintessential Pepperoni Pizza with perfectly crispy edges and a balanced spicy kick, to the creamy and comforting Cheese Pizza, every slice is crafted with care. For those who crave variety, the Half and Half Pizza offers a delightful way to experience multiple flavors in one sitting. Seafood lovers will savor the unique Shrimp Parmesan on a Hero, while the fresh and vibrant Margherita Pizza highlights rich tomato sauce, melting mozzarella, and fragrant basil—a timeless combination that never disappoints.

Beyond pizza, John & Joe’s offers a diverse selection of delectable sides and pasta dishes that elevate the dining experience. Start with crunchy and golden Pepperoni Rolls or indulge in crispy Garlic Knots, which customers rave as “best when warm.” The menu shines with pasta favorites like Penne Alla Vodka, a savory, creamy dish that’s a house favorite, and comforting baked classics such as Lasagna available with meat or vegetable fillings. Fresh salads, from the crisp Antipasto to flavorful Shrimp Salad, offer refreshing balance, while crispy Buffalo Wings and Fried Calamari add a perfect touch of indulgence.

John & Joe's exudes a small, welcoming vibe that makes you feel like more than just a customer—it’s a place where memories are made over shared meals. It’s clear from glowing customer reviews that this pizzeria isn’t just about food; it’s about authentic comfort and consistency. Regular patrons like Julia J. express heartfelt nostalgia, mentioning how their unwavering quality “almost made me cry,” reflecting how food here is tied deeply to home and tradition. Sheenita Press praises the pizza as “so good” and highly recommendable, while young diners like 9-year-old Eloise glowingly remark on the “delicious” thin crust and honest, unpretentious flavors that feel like a true labor of love.

The atmosphere may be modest, but the flavors pack mighty punch as Tessa points out, highlighting a perfectly affordable meal experience—chicken parm with baked ziti and garlicky knots for under $25—that satisfies both taste buds and the wallet. Even Jane Wood, while noting a slight wait time, can't deny the addictive appeal of the pepperoni pizza and warm garlic knots that leave customers eagerly planning their next visit.

Whether you’re in the mood for a quick slice by the slice or a leisurely dinner accompanied by an array of authentic Italian comfort foods, John & Joe’s Pizzeria and Restaurant captures the essence of Bronx pizza culture. They serve not just food, but a delicious slice of community and tradition—making every visit memorable and every meal deeply satisfying.

For a genuine taste of Bronx-style pizza excellence, give John & Joe’s a call at +1 718-409-9776 and prepare to experience pizza that feels like home.